top of page
  • Writer's pictureTom Fowler

Top 10 Questions to Ask a Car Accident Witness

The aftermath of a car crash can be a terrifying experience, with emotions running high and the mind grappling to comprehend what just happened.

In such a scenario, drivers may experience a rush of adrenaline, disorientation, and even anger, making it challenging to think clearly and recall the events. Car accident cases rely more on third-party testimony, as both parties are reluctant to admit fault.

While the immediate aftermath of a car accident may prompt individuals to remember as many details, such as taking photos and exchanging information, securing witness statements is frequently an afterthought.

Drivers must gather and preserve witness statements to avoid the typical insurance battle where it's one person's word against another's.

To aid in this, Tom Fowler Law has created a guide of questions to ask a car accident witness that can be kept in the glove compartment along with the insurance and registration documents. This could significantly impact the outcome of the case in the event of car accidents.

Questions to Ask a Car Accident Witness

Questions to Ask a Car Accident Witness

Here are some of the most common and essential follow-up questions to ask a witness.

Can They Explain in Their Own Words What They Saw?

It is always advisable to start with an open-ended question that invites the accident witness to provide complete detail in their own words.

It is important to avoid asking leading questions, such as "Did you see the other driver hit me?" as this may cause the witness to feel defensive or manipulated into providing a specific answer.

Instead, allowing the witness to establish their narrative is recommended before posing additional, more specific questions for follow-up.

Where Were They Located When the Accident Occurred?

The proximity of a witness to the collision and how they witnessed the event can significantly impact the validity and impact of their testimony. Whether they were right beside the accident, heard it from within a building, or were in the car with the individual, their location holds significant weight.

The other side's lawyer may try to argue that the witness was far from providing a reliable account of where the entire accident occurred. Hence, it is essential to establish their exact location.

To prioritize witnesses before they depart from the scene, it is recommended to identify those closest and with the best view.

Drivers in adjacent lanes may only have looked over after the impact, while drivers behind the accident could have had a clear view of events leading up to the effect. By determining these factors, it is possible to decide which multiple witnesses could provide the most impactful testimony.

What Did They Do After the Accident?

Although a witness may not have seen the events leading up to where the crash occurred, they may still play a role in reconstructing what accident happened immediately afterward.

If the other driver left the scene, the one witness may have noticed details such as the make and model of the car and even captured a photo of the license plate using their phone.

When the witness responds by calling 911 or offering assistance at the accident scene, they also demonstrate the severity level they perceived the accident site to be.

Can They Go into Detail About What They Saw?

To gather more specific information regarding where the crash occurred, follow-up car accident witness questions must be tailored based on the witness's narrative and previous answers obtained.

The exact questions asked may vary based on the nature of the accident and the number of other vehicles involved, but here are some examples of potential follow-up questions:

  • Can they describe the position of each vehicle before the crash, for example, which car was in which lane?

  • Did they observe any erratic movements from either vehicle?

  • Could they assess the speed of the vehicles, did either driver seem to be speeding?

  • Did they see any sudden braking from either driver?

  • What was the time frame between the first sign of trouble and the actual collision? or How fast did the accident occur?

  • Did they notice the traffic signals before the accident, such as if either driver ran a red light or recklessly drove through a yellow light?

  • Did they notice any other traffic violations, such as illegal lane changes or illegal U-turns?

  • Did they witness any damage that was not immediately noticeable to the drivers, such as debris that may have flown off the car?

  • Did they see the other driver post-accident? Were they injured or appear to be under the influence? Did they say anything?

  • Can they describe their actions taken after the accident?

Do They Know Anyone That Was Involved in the Accident?

In the aftermath of a car accident, it's crucial to consider any potential biases that may impact the reliability of a witness's testimony.

To account for this, it's recommended to ask about any relationships the car accident witness may have with the drivers or parties involved in the car accident.

This could include direct connections, such as being a passenger in one of the vehicles, or more subtle relationships that may not immediately be apparent.

Asking about these relationships helps to ensure the validity and impartiality of the witness' account.

What Were They Doing Before the Accident?

The accuracy of a witness's testimony is significantly influenced by the context and clarity of their observation. It is crucial to comprehend the surroundings in which the witness was present during the car accident.

If the witness was distracted and became aware of the crash after the car accident occurred, their testimony might not hold much significance.

Conversely, if the witness had a direct view of the events leading up to the impact while closely following behind the scene, their testimony could be of great importance.

Evaluating the context of the witness's observation requires examining any obstructions in their line of sight, the time of day, and weather conditions.

These factors can significantly impact the visibility and perception of the accident, with better visibility during early morning hours as opposed to the bright midday sun. Weather conditions, such as rain, can also impact what the witness saw, even though it is uncommon in the region.

Asking about the witness's relationship with the parties involved in the accident is recommended to avoid potential biases. Even if the connection is not immediately evident, it is best practice to inquire and establish the context of the witness's observations.

How Did They Feel Before the Car Accident Occurred?

Uncovering the state of mind of the car accident witnesses during the crash can be crucial in determining the validity of their testimony.

It is imperative to assess whether they were in a flustered or rushed state, leisurely strolling, or having a stressful day.

Obtaining information on their state of mind makes it possible to understand their thoughts when the car accident occurred and how that may have affected their observation. This information can be a valuable tool in determining their testimony's reliability.

Do They Have Any Accident-related Knowledge?

Identifying knowledgeable and experienced accident witnesses can be highly beneficial in any legal matter. These individuals may better understand the situation, providing additional valuable insight and adding credibility to their testimony.

This makes it essential to be able to identify these individuals, as their contribution can play a crucial role in the outcome of a case.

Other witnesses with expertise in specific areas may be of particular value. An administrator or a police officer may better understand legal procedures and protocols.

On the other hand, individuals working in the healthcare field may have a deeper understanding of medical issues.

Mechanics or those with technical training may have insights into mechanical or technical problems, making their testimony particularly valuable.

Therefore, identifying other witnesses and considering their areas of expertise can significantly aid in pursuing a favorable outcome.

Is There Anything Else They Would Like to Add?

The witness might have additional information to offer beyond what was initially requested. It is not uncommon for a witness to have knowledge that the interviewer did not think to ask about.

As a result, the interviewer needs to create a comfortable and open environment for the witness to feel encouraged to share any relevant details they may have.

Can They Give Their Contact Information?

Acquiring reliable and up-to-date contact information for the police officer is essential in any investigation or legal matter. This information is crucial in ensuring that all relevant parties can be reached and contacted if needed in the future.

Despite gathering all the necessary information at the scene of the car accident, there may come a time when additional follow-up is required.

It could be in the form of verification of the witness's account by a lawyer or insurance company, or the witness may remember something important that needs to be addressed later.

Contact Tom Fowler Law for Help

Contact Tom Fowler Law for Help

Individuals injured in a car accident do not need to bear the responsibility of investigating the entire incident independently. Tom Fowler Law can prepare you for the questions your car accident lawyer will ask.

In such cases, the stakes are inherently higher. The other driver's insurance company will likely have lawyers working to defend their client or even blame the injured party.

To level the playing field, it is recommended to seek the assistance of a seasoned injury attorney who can conduct a comprehensive investigation of the case, using experts for questioning witnesses so that they can provide testimony on behalf of the injured individual.

In the case of those residing in Des Moines, Iowa, Tom Fowler Law offers a team of experienced trial car accident lawyers who can assist with injury cases. The company is dedicated to ensuring that its clients receive the compensation they deserve and provides free consultations to potential clients.

Furthermore, its compensation structure is such that they are only reimbursed if the car accident case is won, providing added peace of mind for those seeking its services.

6 views0 comments


bottom of page